China’s Communist Party Schools Nurture New Generation

Communist Party schools and academies are inculcating Chinese officials in Xi Jinping Thought as the country shifts in a more authoritarian direction.

Advertisement

Continue reading the main story

Supported by

Continue reading the main story

On a leafy campus in northwest Beijing, dotted with statues of Marx, Mao and other Communist saints, the Chinese leader Xi Jinping is training his “loyal successors,” the next generation of officials who will drive the resurgence of one-party rule.

The Communist Party of China just celebrated 100 years since its founding, and for much of that time the Central Party School and similar academies have been “red cradles.” In these schools, cadres are immersed in the party’s beliefs, which trace back to its early decades as a revolutionary movement. Mr. Xi has preached that re-energized party rule is essential for China’s ascent, and he has urged the schools to produce officials who are proudly and vocally loyal to that cause.

“Our party relied on struggle to get where it is today, and will surely rely on struggle to win the future,” Mr. Xi in March told hundreds of younger officials at the Central Party School, who wrote his words down like attentive pupils. “The dangers and tests ahead will be no less than in the past.”

No audience would seem more receptive to Mr. Xi’s message than the students at China’s thousands of Communist Party-run schools, which train tens of thousands of officials every year. They teach political doctrine, party history, economics and other policy subjects, and Mr. Xi’s ideas are now core to their curriculums.

Mr. Xi offers the “policy principles guiding contemporary China,” Wang Shiquan, a professor at another elite party school, the China Executive Leadership Academy Pudong in Shanghai, said during a recent visit. The school has more than 120 courses using Mr. Xi’s theories, officials at the academy said.

Image

The leafy campus of the Central Party School in Beijing. In such schools, cadres are immersed in the party’s beliefs.Credit…How Hwee Young/EPA, via Shutterstock

As Mr. Xi has taken an increasingly authoritarian grip on China, the party schools have followed. The Central Party School once tolerated, even supported, reformist scholars who have been dismayed by Mr. Xi’s centralization of power, hard-line policies and abolition of term limits. Younger officials are now emerging from the schools stamped by this pugnacious spirit.

One attendee in 2019, Hua Chunying, the Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman, disdainfully swipes at criticisms from Western governments. “China’s success story is the success story of the Chinese Communist Party,” Ms. Hua wrote in a paper for her party school class, which was published in 2019. That story, she wrote, was a “lighthouse pointing to the bright future of the socialist endeavor.”

The Communist Party has run courses to train members almost since its founding. Generations of Chinese leaders have used them to nurture cadres in their own image: revolutionary at first, then embracing economic and political reform in the 1980s, and with a technocratic sheen in more recent decades.

Mao Zedong was a president at the Central Party School. Mr. Xi was president there for five years before becoming the national leader in late 2012. During the 1980s, reformist leaders like Hu Yaobang encouraged the school to produce ideas for an era of opening and political relaxation.

These days, they offer courses on the practicalities of managing a town, county, city or province: how to defuse protests, or how to select officials for promotion. One party school class, described in a recent study, reminded officials visiting flood-stricken areas to wear mud-covered rubber boots as a vivid sign that they were sharing the suffering of residents.

Image

A display featuring Xi Jinping, the leader of China, at the Central Party School in Beijing. Mr. Xi has preached that the party is essential for China’s ascent.Credit…Leo Ramirez/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

“The party schools cultivate this culture of what it is to be a cadre,” said John Fitzgerald, an Australian researcher writing a study of China’s officialdom. “The party school is part of this process of creating this separate elite with its own language, culture and networks.”

The China Executive Leadership Academy recently showcased its efforts to provide a modernized curriculum: part political boot camp, part business school.

“A leader is very busy and comes here for a week or two,” said Professor Wang, the teacher at the academy. “It’s mainly about solving their problems, like how to be a mayor or a party secretary.”

In one course, the student-officials study how to handle crises like riots and natural disasters, such as floods and mudslides. In another, they practice handling media interviews and foreign guests. The academy invites tycoons and officials to teach classes, school officials said.

“We believe in boxing skills being taught by boxers,” said Jiang Junjie, a professor at the academy.

Image

A lecture at China Executive Leadership Academy Pudong in Shanghai last month. The schools teach political doctrine, party history, economics and other policy subjects.Credit…Andrea Verdelli/Getty Images

But classes here and at other party schools are still heavy on political scripture, including Marx and Mao. In recent years, instruction has increasingly centered on Mr. Xi. Flat-panel screens at the Shanghai academy flashed his somber image between announcements.

Study programs for officials include pilgrimages to venerated sites like the Jinggang Mountains, a former base of the revolution where another cadre academy is located.

At the Shanghai academy, a professor rejected the idea that officials received a falsely romantic view of the revolutionary past. The Communist Party has learned from its errors, including the Cultural Revolution of 1966 to 1976, said the professor, Zhang Shengxin.

“We have always treated our mistakes squarely,” she told reporters.

But to Cai Xia, a former party school professor, Mr. Xi has presided over a dangerous eradication of political openness, including at the famous Beijing campus where she once taught.

Image

Hua Chunying, the Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman, at the Central Party School in Beijing in 2019. She disdainfully swipes at criticisms from Western governments.Credit…Leo Ramirez/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Her career at the Central Party School followed China’s arc from a period of relative political openness to Mr. Xi’s authoritarianism. She arrived at the school in 1992, when Deng Xiaoping was loosening the ideological freeze imposed after the bloody June 4, 1989, crackdown on the Tiananmen Square protests. It was a prestigious transfer for Ms. Cai, who had been teaching at a local party school in eastern China.

Over the next two decades, some academics at the school argued for gradual political liberalization, starting inside the party to rid it of corruption and abuses of power, Ms. Cai said. Reform-minded scholars generally kept their ideas within bounds acceptable to leaders. The payoff was that they could carefully advocate change to rising officials.

China’s Tightening Grip

Xi’s Warning: A century after the Communist Party’s founding, China’s leader says foreign powers would “crack their heads and spill blood” if they tried to stop its rise.Behind the Takeover of Hong Kong: One year ago, the city’s freedoms were curtailed with breathtaking speed. But the clampdown was years in the making, and many signals were missed.One Year Later in Hong Kong: Neighbors are urged to report on one another. Children are taught to look for traitors. The Communist Party is remaking the city.Mapping Out China’s Post-Covid Path: Xi Jinping, China’s leader, is seeking to balance confidence and caution as his country strides ahead while other places continue to grapple with the pandemic.A Challenge to U.S. Global Leadership: As President Biden predicts a struggle between democracies and their opponents, Beijing is eager to champion the other side.‘Red Tourism’ Flourishes: New and improved attractions dedicated to the Communist Party’s history, or a sanitized version of it, are drawing crowds ahead of the party’s centennial.

“The Chinese Communist Party actually puts itself above the country, so if the party doesn’t democratize, the country can’t take the step toward democracy,” Ms. Cai said. “We could only try to see if that worked.”

Image

Cai Xia, a former Central Party School professor who was expelled from the Communist Party, laments what she sees as a dangerous eradication of political openness in the schools.

In 2008, a group of researchers at the school issued a blueprint for “comprehensive” political reform to win the party greater public support, cut corruption and increase efficiency. “Freedom of the press is an inevitable trend,” the report said.

Professors at the Central Party School gave hard-hitting lectures on the disasters under Mao, such as the famine brought on by his failed Great Leap Forward. In one course, Ms. Cai said, she pointedly compared countries that generally pursued gradual political change, such as Britain, with those that went through violent revolutions, like Russia.

“I hadn’t even reached the conclusion and one of the students came up to tell me, ‘Teacher Cai, I get it,'” she said.

Minxin Pei, now a professor of political science at Claremont McKenna College in California, said he once helped arrange lectures at the party school by Roderick MacFarquhar, a Harvard professor known for his research on the Cultural Revolution.

“The first words that Rod said were, ‘Today I want to talk about June Fourth,'” Professor Pei said in a telephone interview, referring to the 1989 crackdown. “You could hear a pin drop. Rod basically launched into a lecture about why democracy is needed for China.”

Image

A statue of Mao Zedong at the Central Party School in Beijing.Credit…Mark Schiefelbein/Associated Press

Not even the Central Party School, though, was walled off from the corruption that ate into China’s political elite in recent decades.

School officials struggled to discipline officials studying there who would slip away for nighttime revelry with cronies. Some spirited in mistresses to stay at hotels near the school, Ms. Cai said. A vice mayor from northeast China used his time at the school to slip off to Macau, the gambling enclave on the southern coast, where he bet and lost a fortune in corrupt money.

As president of the Central Party School, Mr. Xi had chided academics who criticized the party. But Ms. Cai waited to see what he would do in power, hoping he would overhaul the political hierarchy.

Nine years later, Ms. Cai is an outspoken critic of China’s authoritarian turn, living in the United States. Last year, the Central Party School expelled her from the party and halted her retirement benefits.

But she said Mr. Xi’s drive for conformity would not change everyone’s thinking, even at the school.

“Outwardly the party appears unified, but underneath there are turbulent undercurrents,” Ms. Cai said. “Inside the party school, some have turned against their former liberal ideas to embrace Xi Jinping; some just say as little as possible.”

Liu Yi contributed research.

Leave a Reply